Public comparison report

ASA Material Family Comparison

3DPIceland Labs

3DPIceland Labs
Generated with 3DPIceland Engineering Platform v60.0.6 WORKFLOW-RELIABILITY - Bug Fixes and Workflow Reliability
2026-08-25 19:04:12

Public-data contract: only explicitly allowlisted MaterialIDs and existing Verified Material Summary scores are included. No measurements or scores are recalculated.
Comparison scope: Stable Material Family preset for ASA. Every included MaterialID has explicit Public reports opt-in.
Materials compared
17
Overall score available
17
All 6 axes available
17

Engineering-axis leaders in this comparison

AxisLeading materialScore
OverallExtrudr DuraPro Emerald Green ASA Green51
TensileEryone Standard White ASA White23
ImpactThorwell Standard ASA ASA Yellow56
StiffnessEryone Standard White ASA GF White82
ConsistencyExtrudr DuraPro Emerald Green ASA Green84
Layer adhesionEryone Standard White ASA GF White39
ThermalEryone Standard Black ASA CF Black46
Overall comparison
Extrudr DuraPro Emerald Green ASA Green
51/100
Eryone Standard Black ASA High Speed Black
48/100
Extrudr DuraPro ASA Red
48/100
Prusa3D Prusament ASA Pro Green
48/100
Eryone Standard White ASA White
46/100
Thorwell Standard ASA ASA Yellow
46/100
Yasin Standard White ASA White
46/100
BambuLab Standard Blue ASA Blue
45/100
Prusa3D Prusament Galaxy Black ASA Black
45/100
Eryone Standard White ASA GF White
44/100
Tensile comparison
Eryone Standard White ASA White
23/100
Prusa3D Prusament ASA Pro Green
23/100
BambuLab Standard Blue ASA Blue
22/100
Thorwell Standard ASA ASA Yellow
22/100
Extrudr DuraPro Emerald Green ASA Green
21/100
Siraya Tech Fiberheart Black ASA GF Black
21/100
Yasin Standard Black ASA GF Black
21/100
Yasin Standard White ASA White
21/100
Yasin Standard Black ASA CF Black
20/100
Eryone Standard Black ASA High Speed Black
19/100
Impact comparison
Thorwell Standard ASA ASA Yellow
56/100
Eryone Standard White ASA White
51/100
Yasin Standard White ASA White
51/100
Eryone Standard Black ASA High Speed Black
50/100
Extrudr DuraPro ASA Red
50/100
Extrudr DuraPro Emerald Green ASA Green
49/100
BambuLab Standard Blue ASA Blue
45/100
Prusa3D Prusament ASA Pro Green
44/100
Prusa3D Prusament Galaxy Black ASA Black
42/100
Prima Creator PrimaSelect ASA Blue
35/100
Stiffness comparison
Eryone Standard White ASA GF White
82/100
Siraya Tech Fiberheart Black ASA GF Black
76/100
Eryone Standard Black ASA CF Black
74/100
BambuLab Standard Blue ASA Blue
73/100
Extrudr DuraPro Neon Green ASA GF Green
73/100
Eryone Standard White ASA White
71/100
Prusa3D Prusament ASA Pro Green
71/100
Extrudr DuraPro ASA Red
68/100
Thorwell Standard ASA ASA Yellow
68/100
Extrudr DuraPro Emerald Green ASA Green
67/100
Thermal comparison
Eryone Standard Black ASA CF Black
46/100
Siraya Tech Fiberheart Black ASA GF Black
46/100
BambuLab Standard Blue ASA Blue
45/100
Eryone Standard White ASA White
45/100
Prusa3D Prusament ASA Pro Green
45/100
Thorwell Standard ASA ASA Yellow
45/100
Extrudr DuraPro Neon Green ASA GF Green
43/100
Yasin Standard White ASA White
43/100
Extrudr DuraPro ASA CF Black
42/100
Extrudr DuraPro ASA Red
42/100

Materials and evidence context

MaterialIDMaterialManufacturerProduct lineTypeReinforcementTest coverageEngineering axes
MAT0014Extrudr DuraPro Emerald Green ASA GreenExtrudrDuraProASAComplete6/6
MAT0211Eryone Standard Black ASA High Speed BlackEryoneStandardASAComplete6/6
MAT0016Extrudr DuraPro ASA RedExtrudrDuraProASAComplete6/6
MAT0015Prusa3D Prusament ASA Pro GreenPrusa3DPrusamentASAComplete6/6
MAT0216Eryone Standard White ASA WhiteEryoneStandardASAComplete6/6
MAT0148Thorwell Standard ASA ASA YellowThorwellStandardASAComplete6/6
MAT0017Yasin Standard White ASA WhiteYasinStandardASAComplete6/6
MAT0179BambuLab Standard Blue ASA BlueBambuLabStandardASAComplete6/6
MAT0012Prusa3D Prusament Galaxy Black ASA BlackPrusa3DPrusamentASAComplete6/6
MAT0218Eryone Standard White ASA GF WhiteEryoneStandardASAGFComplete6/6
MAT0010Yasin Standard Black ASA GF BlackYasinStandardASAGFComplete6/6
MAT0197Siraya Tech Fiberheart Black ASA GF BlackSiraya TechFiberheartASAGFComplete6/6
MAT0011Extrudr DuraPro Neon Green ASA GF GreenExtrudrDuraProASAGFComplete6/6
MAT0009Yasin Standard Black ASA CF BlackYasinStandardASACFComplete6/6
MAT0213Eryone Standard Black ASA CF BlackEryoneStandardASACFComplete6/6
MAT0013Prima Creator PrimaSelect ASA BluePrima CreatorPrimaSelectASAComplete6/6
MAT0008Extrudr DuraPro ASA CF BlackExtrudrDuraProASACFComplete6/6

Side-by-side engineering scores

MaterialIDMaterialManufacturerReinforcementCoverageEvidenceOverallTensileImpactStiffnessConsistencyLayer adhesionThermalFixture °CMethodThermal limitationMSRP USD/kg
MAT0014Extrudr DuraPro Emerald Green ASA GreenExtrudrComplete6/651/10021/10049/10067/10084/10035/10042/10083 °C3dp-thermal-deflection-fixture-v1Nearby BlueDOT probe-indicated fixture temperature from a non-standard comparative 3DPIceland method; not ASTM D648, ISO 75, specimen temperature, certified HDT or a manufacturer limit.$21.97
MAT0211Eryone Standard Black ASA High Speed BlackEryoneComplete6/648/10019/10050/10066/10083/10023/10041/10082 °C3dp-thermal-deflection-fixture-v1Nearby BlueDOT probe-indicated fixture temperature from a non-standard comparative 3DPIceland method; not ASTM D648, ISO 75, specimen temperature, certified HDT or a manufacturer limit.$17.50
MAT0016Extrudr DuraPro ASA RedExtrudrComplete6/648/10019/10050/10068/10080/10021/10042/10083 °C3dp-thermal-deflection-fixture-v1Nearby BlueDOT probe-indicated fixture temperature from a non-standard comparative 3DPIceland method; not ASTM D648, ISO 75, specimen temperature, certified HDT or a manufacturer limit.$21.97
MAT0015Prusa3D Prusament ASA Pro GreenPrusa3DComplete6/648/10023/10044/10071/10081/10024/10045/10090 °C3dp-thermal-deflection-fixture-v1Nearby BlueDOT probe-indicated fixture temperature from a non-standard comparative 3DPIceland method; not ASTM D648, ISO 75, specimen temperature, certified HDT or a manufacturer limit.$26.40
MAT0216Eryone Standard White ASA WhiteEryoneComplete6/646/10023/10051/10071/10077/1008/10045/10089 °C3dp-thermal-deflection-fixture-v1Nearby BlueDOT probe-indicated fixture temperature from a non-standard comparative 3DPIceland method; not ASTM D648, ISO 75, specimen temperature, certified HDT or a manufacturer limit.$15.00
MAT0148Thorwell Standard ASA ASA YellowThorwellComplete6/646/10022/10056/10068/10076/10010/10045/10089 °C3dp-thermal-deflection-fixture-v1Nearby BlueDOT probe-indicated fixture temperature from a non-standard comparative 3DPIceland method; not ASTM D648, ISO 75, specimen temperature, certified HDT or a manufacturer limit.$33.60
MAT0017Yasin Standard White ASA WhiteYasinComplete6/646/10021/10051/10052/10084/10022/10043/10086 °C3dp-thermal-deflection-fixture-v1Nearby BlueDOT probe-indicated fixture temperature from a non-standard comparative 3DPIceland method; not ASTM D648, ISO 75, specimen temperature, certified HDT or a manufacturer limit.$27.52
MAT0179BambuLab Standard Blue ASA BlueBambuLabComplete6/645/10022/10045/10073/10072/10011/10045/10089 °C3dp-thermal-deflection-fixture-v1Nearby BlueDOT probe-indicated fixture temperature from a non-standard comparative 3DPIceland method; not ASTM D648, ISO 75, specimen temperature, certified HDT or a manufacturer limit.$47.92
MAT0012Prusa3D Prusament Galaxy Black ASA BlackPrusa3DComplete6/645/10018/10042/10060/10082/10021/10039/10077 °C3dp-thermal-deflection-fixture-v1Nearby BlueDOT probe-indicated fixture temperature from a non-standard comparative 3DPIceland method; not ASTM D648, ISO 75, specimen temperature, certified HDT or a manufacturer limit.$34.00
MAT0218Eryone Standard White ASA GF WhiteEryoneGFComplete6/644/10017/10028/10082/10054/10039/10037/10074 °C3dp-thermal-deflection-fixture-v1Nearby BlueDOT probe-indicated fixture temperature from a non-standard comparative 3DPIceland method; not ASTM D648, ISO 75, specimen temperature, certified HDT or a manufacturer limit.$16.50
MAT0010Yasin Standard Black ASA GF BlackYasinGFComplete6/644/10021/10032/10065/10079/10023/10042/10083 °C3dp-thermal-deflection-fixture-v1Nearby BlueDOT probe-indicated fixture temperature from a non-standard comparative 3DPIceland method; not ASTM D648, ISO 75, specimen temperature, certified HDT or a manufacturer limit.$28.80
MAT0197Siraya Tech Fiberheart Black ASA GF BlackSiraya TechGFComplete6/643/10021/10027/10076/10077/10017/10046/10091 °C3dp-thermal-deflection-fixture-v1Nearby BlueDOT probe-indicated fixture temperature from a non-standard comparative 3DPIceland method; not ASTM D648, ISO 75, specimen temperature, certified HDT or a manufacturer limit.$34.39
MAT0011Extrudr DuraPro Neon Green ASA GF GreenExtrudrGFComplete6/641/10015/10020/10073/10076/10022/10043/10085 °C3dp-thermal-deflection-fixture-v1Nearby BlueDOT probe-indicated fixture temperature from a non-standard comparative 3DPIceland method; not ASTM D648, ISO 75, specimen temperature, certified HDT or a manufacturer limit.$42.27
MAT0009Yasin Standard Black ASA CF BlackYasinCFComplete6/641/10020/10019/10063/10077/10025/10042/10083 °C3dp-thermal-deflection-fixture-v1Nearby BlueDOT probe-indicated fixture temperature from a non-standard comparative 3DPIceland method; not ASTM D648, ISO 75, specimen temperature, certified HDT or a manufacturer limit.$33.44
MAT0213Eryone Standard Black ASA CF BlackEryoneCFComplete6/640/10013/10019/10074/10078/10016/10046/10091 °C3dp-thermal-deflection-fixture-v1Nearby BlueDOT probe-indicated fixture temperature from a non-standard comparative 3DPIceland method; not ASTM D648, ISO 75, specimen temperature, certified HDT or a manufacturer limit.$17.50
MAT0013Prima Creator PrimaSelect ASA BluePrima CreatorComplete6/639/10019/10035/10060/10067/10013/10042/10084 °C3dp-thermal-deflection-fixture-v1Nearby BlueDOT probe-indicated fixture temperature from a non-standard comparative 3DPIceland method; not ASTM D648, ISO 75, specimen temperature, certified HDT or a manufacturer limit.$22.52
MAT0008Extrudr DuraPro ASA CF BlackExtrudrCFComplete6/636/10015/10014/10065/10069/10016/10042/10084 °C3dp-thermal-deflection-fixture-v1Nearby BlueDOT probe-indicated fixture temperature from a non-standard comparative 3DPIceland method; not ASTM D648, ISO 75, specimen temperature, certified HDT or a manufacturer limit.$21.97
Results are comparative 3DPIceland measurements and do not replace manufacturer datasheets or accredited laboratory testing.

Testing methodology · Engineering methodology whitepaper · Download PDF